07-26-2015, 06:58 AM
If you don't mind, let me add as to how scheduling and rescheduling works (and what you can do to...well... at least get an explanation).
Congress delegated powers via DOJÂ to schedule drugs under the CSA to the DEA in the early 70s. That's pretty clear. Of course, that doesn't mean that can do things nilly willy, and the DEA does a lot of things, not just raids that you see on TV, not just reprimanding our doctors for no good reason. They're an administrative agency who is generally given what's called "Chevron Deference" in their decisionmaking - meaning (in very simple terms) unless something goes way wrong, courts will defer to their decision. The Chevron decision is probably the most cited decision in U.S. history and you shouldn't read it unless you're bored as hell or an admin nerd like me.
Every document they've published and are required to be published are online. They are here:Â https://www.federalregister.gov/agencies...nistration
There are of course things they don't publish. You can submit a FOIA. You may not hear back for a year. But let's just look at the stuff they do publish first. They generally publish three kinds of documents: notices, rules, and proposed rules. Proposed rules are frequently open by law for interested parties aka Americans at large to comment in order for the agency to address issues and further refine rules. Rules are final decisions. Notices are also final decisions but it's not so much rulemaking but rather telling you the status of something.
Furthermore, only some proposed rules - namely legislative rules - are open to notice and commentary. These open new legal obligations and are required to have public input. I comment on every proposed leg rule that I have any sort of expertise or stake in. It'd be cool if you can do the same. On the other hand, interpretive rules are simply rules that just reword or reemphasize certain preexisting obligations and rule and do not require this process. This kind of stuff goes to court all the time.
Hope you're not bored yet. Let me show you what they usually do. Tons of notices. Let's look at this:Â
The DEA manages substance distribution and manufacturing and importing (this is why love letters exist, some simply haven't paid the proper import duties). One of their jobs is to determine who can distribute medication and who can't. https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...order#h-10 is a good example. Dr. Zaidi is a pain doc in Ohio who gave out Oxy liberally and was busted in a sting and the case is about whether he's losing his license alongside a lot of other procedural stuff. This is one type of thing they publish.
They register importers of medication (https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...ticals-inc). Also, manufacturers need to register as well (https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...ed-usa-llc).
Then we get to the good part. This is a sample proposed legislative rule that requires notice and commentary. Basically:
"The proposed year 2016 aggregate production quotas and assessment of annual needs represent those quantitiesof schedule I and II controlled substances, and the list I chemicals ephedrine, pseudoephedrine, and phenylpropanolamine, to be manufactured in the United States in 2016 to provide for the estimated medical, scientific, research, and industrial needs of the United States, lawful export requirements, and the establishment and maintenance of reserve stocks. These proposals include estimated imports of ephedrine, pseudoephedrine, and phenylpropanolamine but do not include estimated imports of controlled substances for use in industrial processes."
They would like to set numbers as to how much of each they can manufacture or import here. https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...essment-of
Then you can comment on whether it's too much or too little. With cause, of course.
Ok, let's look at actual scheduling. In May, the DEA gave notice that they will but aceytl-fentanyl on the temporary schedule I list as an emergency. Here's the notice: https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...schedule-i and for public health reasons it could be placed there for 3 years without notice or commentary for 3 years, but obviously they have to outline the reasons, which they did here. The final order came in on 7/17. https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...schedule-i
They also take things off like this:Â https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...val-of-123 I have no idea what this is but they apparently found no need to schedule it and after notice and commentary, will probably unschedule it.
What's disheartening is that unlike many other agencies they get what they want usually. USCIS reduced its 18 page green card application to six last few weeks, but since the DEA's purview is so narrow, there are few ways to convincingly make an argument to not schedule something.
An example would be Tramadol. It was scheduled into Schedule IV in 2013. Since it was a formal rulemaking process, there was the opportunity for interested parties to ask for a hearing, which happened. https://www.federalregister.gov/articles...chedule-iv
"Individuals Are Taking Tramadol in Amounts Sufficient To Create a Hazard to Their Health or to the Safety of Other Individuals or to the Community"
"There Is a Significant Diversion of Tramadol From Legitimate Drug Channels"
"Individuals Are Taking Tramadol on Their Own Initiative Rather Than on the Basis of Medical Advice From a Practitioner Licensed by Law to Administer Such Drugs"
"Tramadol is so Related in Its Action to a Drug or Other Substance Already Listed as Having a Potential for Abuse To Make It Likely That It Will Have the Same Potential for Abuse as Such Substance, Thus Making It Reasonable To Assume That There May Be Significant Diversions From Legitimate Channels, Significant Use Contrary to or Without Medical Advice, or That It Has a Substantial Capability of Creating Hazards to the Health of the User or to the Safety of the Community"
Since these are, essentially, all true but silly reasoning (because it happens to most drugs), well, Tramadol ultimately was Schedule IVed. However, a review process did find that it did not have the harmful abilities of Schedule III or II opoids and Schedule IV was appropriate. Small victories.,
So now you know the gist of what the DEA does and how they do it.. They do other things like listing out what;s scheduled, they do research, however, when I submitted a commentary about patient access of rescheduling Opiate/APAP from 3 to 2 (legit conern, I worked in Indian Tribal Court that summer, very remote), the answer was "that's none of our business".
I hope this gives you a bit more understanding of how the Scheduling system works. One can petition to unschedule things, but it requires a fair bit of work and hard time for tough crime, right?

